Sermon on Matthew 25:31-46

Pastor Jennifer Garcia

Today’s Gospel reading is the latest in our series of Jesus’ teachings about what his followers should do while they wait for his return. There was a parable about treating others well, preparing for Jesus’ arrival, and using resources to boldly care for others.

But they all have troubling imagery, and today’s reading is no different. The binary of sheep or goat reeks of judgment, and the closing line about “eternal punishment” is unsettling.

I remember my grandma saying on more than one occasion, “I don’t want to be a goat!”She may have been saying it a little tongue in cheek, but to at least a certain extent, this reading scared her. She was a faithful person, a loving spouse and parent and grandparent, and the quintessential “church lady” who ironed paraments in her spare time.Surely, she didn’t have anything to worry about!

And still, she did worry.

Maybe that’s part of the remedy for this parable’s fear-inducing imagery.

If this reading unsettles you, that might be a good sign that you care about acting like Jesus.

And as good Lutherans, we know that we can’t save ourselves by doing good works. Jesus saved us, once and for all, and there’s nothing we can do to make God love us any more or any less.

No matter how many people we feed or welcome or clothe or nurse or visit, we can’t earn our way into God’s love. Thank God!

So, if this reading makes your stomach sink, that means that you recognize what God has already done for you. Let that fear turn to gratitude!

And out of that gratitude for what God has already done for us, we’re free to love and serve our neighbors in the ways Jesus described in this teaching. That’s how we can show our gratitude this Thankoffering Sunday and the week of this Thanksgiving holiday.

Let’s see in this parable, not a punishing rubric to live up to, butan illustration of the deep care and concern Jesus has for those the world treats as expendable.

Today is not only Thankoffering Sunday, but Christ the King Sunday, the last Sunday of the church year, when we recognize that no earthly ruler comes close to Christ’s power and authority.

With power and authority like that, Christ could be a tyrant, caring only for his own majesty and being glorified by everyone.

But that’s not what we see in today’s reading. We see instead that Christ is in complete solidarity with the poor and oppressed: “just as you did it to one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did it to me.”

Christ the King is present in the least, the last, and the lost.

Christ the King was exalted by being lifted up on a cross.

And, though he took care of our salvation 2,000 years ago, so we don’t have to live in fear, we’re missing out on joy now if we ignore the needs of our most marginalized, oppressed, and excluded neighbors.

If we refuse to imitate our Savior’s concern for the least of these, then we’re turning our backs on the Beloved Community that is here and now.

At the risk of alluding to Christmas too early, if we reject that kinship with our neighbors, we’re becoming like Ebenezer Scrooge. But, don’t worry, just like for Scrooge, there’s still hope for all of us.

I want to share a story from Kate Bowler’s new book, Joyful,Anyway. She’s an author, professor, and stage four colon cancer survivor, and she has a beautiful way of talking about the hard truths of life in meaningful ways. This book talks about joy and, in this particular chapter, joy’s relationship to gratitude, which is appropriate for Thankoffering Sunday.

In this story, she talks about going to see her former, now-retired therapist, Henry,in a production of A Christmas Carol.

“When the curtains parted, Scrooge the former psychologist walked onstage, utterly transformed. The man with a gentle face and an attentive expression looked positively stooped by a lifetime of resentments and solitary bitterness. He played the miserly embittered Scrooge like he had never known a day of gladness. He was, true to the character, a complete dick to all who loved him. He raged against his nephew's hospitality, the poor's neediness, and the uselessness of parties. By the time he was confronted by the ghosts, he had harrumphed his way through his heartless past, his refusal of present joys, and his desolate future. We watched how he hated the world that did not love him back.

But I could not get over the crying. Henry's Scrooge cried.

He began when he realized that he had misused his life and squandered every good gift, but was he supposed to cry during the entire second act?

Then, the ghosts fell away, the bell struck midnight, and Scrooge was back in his nightgown in his own room, returned to the living just in the nick of time: he can change.

And he is filled with joy.

"I don't know what to do!" Scrooge says, laughing, returned by the ghosts and dumped off in the familiarity of his bedroom. He is euphoric. "I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a school-boy. I am as giddy as a drunken man!" But tell that to his face.

Scrooge cried and cried until long, thundering applause insisted that he take a deep bow, and when the curtains fell, I clapped and whistled until my palms were red and ears were ringing.

I waited by the stage door as the crowds thinned and Bob Cratchit found his wife and Tiny Tim was collected by his parents. Scrooge emerged with watery eyes still streaking eyeliner down his chalky cheeks. I couldn't help but reach for a hug when I saw him.

I asked, immediately: "Are you okay?"

He chuckled softly. "I'm okay."

"What brought up so much emotion? You're an amazing actor and maybe you felt nothing, but there is also a lot going on with the character."

"It's just ..." He paused. "Scrooge is so grateful. And I amso, so grateful."

I wanted to ask him why. Was Henry grateful to have been able to use his gifts so masterfully? Was it because it is just so lovely to be part of something bigger than yourself? Was there something private he wouldn't want to tell me about his deep relief that he had been given back the world as it is?

There is a crystalline quality to the way I think back on that night, about Scrooge, remembering him shuffling around, grateful and tired and very, very weepy. About how he had been taken through the past and present and future, and was horrified by what he saw: selfishness, greed, stubbornness, in-difference, a life atrophied from lack of love. And about how Scrooge laughed and laughed as though he were entirely out of practice. He had heard the bell strike midnight and felt so very verylucky, and seemed to know a little more about how joy thaws our hearts and quickens us.

For a moment, our heartbreak does not matter. It does not matter. It does not matter.

We are alive—like Lazarus, briefly resurrected. Whatever has weighed down our souls is gone and our spirits lift up, up, up.

Joy is, at bottom, the belief that existence is good. That to be is good.”

 

When we release our fear of judgment, relying instead on God’s grace, we’re freed to treat our neighbor gratefully as we would Jesus himself. And that opens our hearts to joy. Joy is available to us now, sometimes in the most unlikely places: Scrooge’s new beginning, the tears of a retired therapist, and maybe in our hearts today.

Receive the joy and love and delight our Jesus has for each of us and each of our neighbors, now and forever. Amen.